Carrier Contacts
We have highly trained and skilled staff that are here to serve you and assist in handling your account for any and every product you bought from us, whether that is Health, Life, Auto or Home. CMI Insurance has over a hundred carrier relations, and therefore the following information does not pertain to all of our customers. As an industry practice some of our Auto & Home Carriers ask that when filing for a claim or checking on an existing claim that you contact them directly using the information listed below.

Please know if you are having trouble reaching one of the few Carrier's listed below, prefer to use our customer service anyway, or if there is not a phone number listed for your Carrier, please contact us and we would be happy to assist you. We are here for each and every customer and want to ensure you have the absolute best service possible!

Most companies have a unique contact for claims and for making a payment, so be sure to select the appropriate division you wish to contact. Many of the companies listed below also offer online claims that you can find in the links provided.
File a Claim invis Make a Payment
 Allied 800-282-1446
 American Modern 800-375-2075
 Assurant Specialty Property 800-245-1505
 Auto Owners 800-346-0346
 Encompass 800-588-7400, option #4
 Foremost 800-274-7865 (Pers Auto)
800-527-3907 (Pers Other)
866-967-5256 (Workers Comp)
800-435-7764 (Business Other)
 Glatfelter Insurance 800-233-1957
 Grange 800-445-3030
 Hagerty 800-762-2628, option #3
 The Hartford 800-243-5860
 Kemi 800-640-5364
 Kentucky Self Insurer's Fund 502-245-8395
 Kesa 800-367-5372
 Motorists Mutual 800-876-8766
 Ohio Casualty 866-223-9928
 Philadelphia Insurance 800-765-9749
 Progressive 800-274-4499
 Safeco 800-332-3226
 Travelers 800-252-4633
 Zurich Insurance 800-987-3373